I was excited for Fanatics. My previous dining experiences there had been excellent. Their wings are great. Their Reuben Sandwich on the pretzel bread is fantastic. Their burger, however, left me a little disappointed.
Fanatics is the brain-child of Matt Day, who is the actual child of Clark Day, famed Kingston restaurateur and founder of Aquaterra Bistro at the Radisson. After Shoeless Joe's lost its liquor license one too many times, Day bought the place, gutted it, installed about 693 televisions (estimates vary), and offered up a classy version of your typical bar and pub food. And the food is - usually - very good.
The burgers are made of 8oz. of ground angus beef. In a newspaper article posted by the door, Day boasts the quality and purity of the beef, stating that there is no filler in the patties, not even salt. This, I think, is where the problem lies. Plain ground beef, especially beef as lean as this, is kinda bland. And 8oz is a whole lotta bland. The burger patties are very thick, so with every bite there is a noticeable void of flavour, which I did not care for. Also, plain lean ground beef has trouble sticking together on its own, and my burger fell apart a couple times. To be honest, it was a bit of a slog getting through the whole thing.

Fanatics offers on its menu a Naked Burger, three dressed up burgers (the Fanatic, the Mushroom Melt, and the Southwest), and their veggie option. I had the Fanatics Burger. Topped with jalepeno havarti, two strips of bacon, and an onion ring, this burger was huge. Even after I removed the onion ring (I don't like onion rings), it was still a challenge to bit into. The cheese and bacon, however, were very good and whatever the mayo-like sauce was underneath the patty, was both peculiar and delicious.
I also got to try the Southwast Burger with bacon, caramelized onions, jack & cheddar cheese, and Jack Daniels BBQ sauce. I've said it before - I'm not a fan of BBQ sauce. But, like before, I found the Jack Daniels sauce quite delicious. Maybe I should rethink my stance on BBQ sauce.
The fries were the 'dark style', as I have taken to calling it. Regular size and appearing to be over done, but they're actually rather soft, just a darker shade of brown an with an ever-so-slight taste of burnt. Sometimes, this style works. Today, not so much.
The burgers range from $7.99 to $9.99, with extra for salad or poutine substitutions. Extra toppings $1.49.
2.5 Pickles out of 5.